What Plants Don’t Work Well with Hydroponics?

Hydroponics is a method of growing plants without soil, using mineral nutrient solutions in water. Many plants grow well hydroponically, especially when the system is tailored to their specific needs. However, there are some plants that may not be ideally suited to hydroponic methods for various reasons:

1. Woody Perennials: Plants like trees and shrubs that grow for many years and develop extensive root systems might not be ideal for hydroponic setups due to the space and long-term maintenance they require.
2. Tubers and Bulbs: Some plants like potatoes, carrots, and onions grow underground and can be challenging to grow hydroponically. They require special systems, like the use of an aeroponic system, to grow properly, and even then, it may not be as efficient as growing them in soil.
3. Deep-Rooted Plants: Some plants have naturally deep or extensive root systems that might be too large for typical hydroponic containers. For these, you’d need a system with a deep water culture or a modified setup.
4. Plants that Prefer Dry Conditions: Some plants, like many desert-dwelling succulents and cacti, naturally thrive in dry conditions. While it’s possible to grow them hydroponically, their water and nutrient needs differ greatly from more commonly grown hydroponic plants, so they might be more challenging for beginners.
5. Some Herbs: Some herbs, like rosemary, prefer well-draining soil and might be susceptible to root rot if watered too much, a potential issue in some hydroponic setups.
6. Plants with Specific Mycorrhizal Relationships: Some plants have co-evolved with specific fungi in the soil, forming beneficial mycorrhizal relationships. These plants may struggle in hydroponic setups that lack these fungi, unless the hydroponic nutrient solution is specially tailored to their needs.

That being said, many plants can be adapted to hydroponic conditions with the right adjustments in terms of light, nutrients, and water. Before setting up a hydroponic system for a specific plant, it’s important to research the plant’s specific needs and match those to an appropriate hydroponic setup.

Click here to learn Why don t plants drown in hydroponics?